Post
by Murfreesboro » Tue Nov 08, 2011 9:03 am
Oh, I haven't seen that one. Doesn't he play (all) (many) parts in it?
The Patrick Stewart one from back in the '90s is interesting. I prefer Scott's interpretation, but Stewart looks the part perhaps more than Scott does, and he's English. Also, I think Joel Grey's Ghost of Christmas Past in the Stewart version is the absolute best portrayal of that character ever on film. I am very, very familiar with the original novella, re-reading it almost every year of my life since I was 15 (seriously, I can recite passages). Anyway, The Ghost of Christmas Past is described in a highly surreal way, so he is very difficult to cast or envision. Most productions don't even try. But Joel Grey pretty much nails it, I think.
I think Edward Woodward's Ghost of Christmas Present in the George C. Scott version is the best I've ever seen. He gets the sarcasm of that ghost perfectly. The scenes between him & Scott just crackle.
What I love about Scott's interpretation is that he gets Scrooge's intelligence. Scrooge is unlikeable in the beginning of the book, but he is very quick-witted. Scott gets that about him. He humanizes him better than any other actor I have ever seen in that role.